blog
“The expected performance of influence campaigns still very little includes the carbon impact, even of the most committed players”
On the occasion of the launch of the Carbon Footprint Influence Marketing Calculator by Kolsquare, our partner and communication agency for impact brands, Elodie Dupré, Head of Media and Influence Greenstory, tells us her tips on how to reduce the environmental impact of our dynamic and emerging industry.
Greenstory
Greenstory is a branding and communication agency that has been supporting brands and impact projects for more than 10 years. From the start, the founders of Greenstory, Elodie Dupré and Camille Cian, were convinced that the Influence lever is absolutely key in a marketing strategy, but only if it is finely worked, in line with the advertiser's DNA. They know perfectly the profiles of KOLs, who are both aware of responsible consumption and talented prescribers, and master the co-creation of original devices that make it possible to convey the key messages of their customers, in accordance with the editorial guidelines of content creators. In this interview, Elodie Dupré, Head of Media and Influence explains how the agency integrates carbon footprint issues into the design of its influence campaigns.
How do you assess the level of awareness of influencers and influencer marketers about the environmental impact of their activities?
Serious discussions about the carbon footprint of influencer marketing activities are really recent!
So-called “committed” influencers are for the most part aware of the general impact of their digital activity on the environment, but rarely in a precise and numerical manner.
In reality, influencers who are interested in the more responsible practice of their profession rely on common sense to limit the negative consequences: as little over-packaging as possible in packages, the limitation of air travel when possible, etc. But this affects more the upstream than the downstream of the production of content. Because, even if video broadcasting weighs heavily on the carbon footprint of an operation, advertisers, agencies and influencers will tend to use this format, since the algorithm of the most used social platforms, such as Instagram for example, greatly favors video creation. This type of living content is very popular and allows us to achieve our business goals with really interesting quantitative and qualitative results. So yes, most influencers and our client brands want to be able to take more account of these environmental aspects, but not at the expense of excellent marketing reports... Today, the expected performance of influence campaigns still very little integrates the carbon impact, even of the most committed players.
However, it is essential to start asking questions about “how to optimize an influence campaign, taking into account its environmental impact throughout the chain”. Always ask yourself: what can we do about it? You have to be ingenious! At Greenstory, we have been developing our social media editorial recommendations for several years now by capitalizing on the rules of “slow content”, for a content ecology! We clearly aim at the recyclability of qualitative productions.
Another practice, certainly marginal, but which has multiple advantages, is hand-carrying. Since the Greenstory teams are based in Paris, Nantes, Lyon and Bordeaux, we like to meet content creators to give them our customers' products in person, over a coffee. It's low impact (long live the subway, the tram, the bike!) , very effective in getting key messages across the brand and products and, last but not least, it humanizes the agency x influencer relationship; it's really nice and rich to see each other IRL! In fact, that's how I met the person who then became my partner 7 years ago: Camille. She was already the agent of the green influencer Coline and I was giving her customer products over coffee when we had this professional crush!
You work with impact brands that are already aware of the need to reduce our impact on the environment: how willing will they be to compare campaign performance to its carbon footprint and to make changes?
As a marketing consulting agency whose environmental considerations are integrated into our business thinking, our role is also to make our clients aware of the overall coherence of their actions. If they sell products that respect nature and humans, the way they are promoted must also be as low-impact as possible... and influence is one of them.
We are very lucky, because all our customers, from start-ups to large SMEs, all sectors combined (food, beauty, maintenance, mobility, tourism, associations, private, public...) sincerely want to be part of a continuous improvement process and are therefore very attentive to what we want to change each year, with them.
Over the 13 years of Greenstory, how have your activities evolved to take into account and reduce carbon impact?
A good example is the influence program that we are developing for our historical client, the organic baby food brand GOOD GOÛT. About ten years ago, we sent massive shipments (several hundred per year) of packages of discovered products to all the digital mums who requested them, without necessarily judging the precise relevance of each profile. We had Good Goûté products delivered to our offices and then repacked the packages that we sent back to the influencers. Small dishes, fruit bottles, and cookie packages were over-protected with plastic wrappers to avoid breakage...
Today, thanks to our detailed knowledge of the world of parental influencers and with the help of the Kolsquare platform, we identify in real time the most core target profiles on the subject of the current campaign. The data “audience credibility rate” (+60%), “share of the community living in France” (+70%) and “engagement rate” (high average, depending on the volume of the community), allow us to exclusively address interesting KOLs with real potential as future brand buyers, without wasting time, energy... and without unnecessary carbon expenditure.
In addition, we stopped sending the packages ourselves. It is always our customers who manage the packaging of influencers. Result: we avoid an unnecessary journey for products and therefore a reduction in the carbon impact. In addition, it allows packages to be sent more quickly to interested parties.
We have set up a collaborative file between Good Goût and Greenstory that optimizes the package sending process; in short, a collaboration hand in hand with multiple advantages!
Finally, we stopped sending “surprise packages” to influencers, without having asked them for their agreement and interest first. This definitively eliminates the risk of deploying energy-intensive actions that would potentially be a waste of time.
Today, the performance of our influence actions is optimal for Good Goût with an online sales objective that was greatly exceeded during our last campaign: ROI X 4.9!
What are the challenges associated with measuring and reducing the carbon impact of influencer marketing?
The difficulties are linked to the collection of information, which can be long and tedious, both for the advertiser and for the influencer. And of course also: how not to depreciate performance.
The KPIs for the moment will mainly be the quantity and weight of packages, as well as the distances travelled.
What are the areas in which you think there are “quick wins” to reduce the carbon impact of future influence campaigns?
In general, we still see too many advertisers who, without a tool like Kolsquare, manage their influence campaigns in a somewhat artisanal way and send numerous packages to “influencers” who, in reality, are very far from their goals. Without even talking about accounts with dubious communities, there are also simply well-known influencers who we discover that less than half of their community lives on French soil. However, for a brand that distributes exclusively at the national level, this is of limited interest.
Among the quick-win actions for the entire profession, I would say:
- Better control the profiles to be addressed (thanks to a tool like Kolsquare)
- No more spontaneous “surprise” package shipments
- Stop overpackaging when possible (difficult with glass products...)
- Study innovative solutions in terms of responsible packaging
What will be the interest for an agency like Greenstory to be able to visualize in Kolsquare an estimate of the carbon impact of content broadcast as part of an influence campaign?
In the medium term, I am convinced that this dimension will be entirely among the elements to be considered prior to the deployment of an influence campaign. Wherever we can do something, let's do it! But it seems essential to me to carry out this work in a collegial manner, by raising the awareness of all stakeholders (Meta included!) and by thinking together about possible adjustments.
About Kolsquare
Kolsquare is Europe’s leading Influencer Marketing platform, offering a data-driven solution that empowers brands to scale their KOL (Key Opinion Leader) marketing strategies through authentic partnerships with top creators.
Kolsquare’s advanced technology helps marketing professionals seamlessly identify the best content creators by filtering their content and audience, while also enabling them to build, manage, and optimize campaigns from start to finish. This includes measuring results and benchmarking performance against competitors.
With a thriving global community of influencer marketing experts, Kolsquare serves hundreds of customers—including Coca-Cola, Netflix, Sony Music, Publicis, Sézane, Sephora, Lush, and Hermès—by leveraging the latest Big Data, AI, and Machine Learning technologies. Our platform taps into an extensive network of KOLs with more than 5,000 followers across 180 countries on Instagram, TikTok, X (Twitter), Facebook, YouTube, and Snapchat.
As a Certified B Corporation, Kolsquare leads the way in promoting Responsible Influence, championing transparency, ethical practices, and meaningful collaborations that inspire positive change.
Since October 2024, Kolsquare has become part of the Team.Blue group, one of the largest private tech companies in Europe, and a leading digital enabler for businesses and entrepreneurs across Europe. Team.Blue brings together over 60 successful brands in web hosting, domains, e-commerce, online compliance, lead generation, application solutions, and social media.
Influencer Marketing Newsletter